Popular right now

FILM

I Play Rocky Joins Rocky III in CinemaScore’s Rare A+ Club

Opening-night audiences gave the Rocky making-of drama the highest grade CinemaScore hands out, making it the first mainstream drama in years to earn one, just as the film expands to 2,000 theaters for the original Rocky's 50th anniversary weekend.

Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone and Stephan James as Carl Weathers sit on a locker room bench in I Play Rocky
Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone and Stephan James as Carl Weathers in I Play Rocky. (Photo: Claire Folger / Amazon MGM Studios)

Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky expanded into theaters across the country on Friday, and opening-night audiences handed it the highest grade moviegoers can give: an A+ CinemaScore. CinemaScore has polled audiences as they leave theaters since 1979, and in all that time only 136 films have ever earned the perfect score.

The grade puts the film in remarkable company, including one member of its own family. Rocky III earned an A+ back in 1982, so the movie about how the original Rocky got made now shares the franchise’s rarest audience honor. It is also Farrelly’s second A+: his Green Book earned the same grade in 2018.

CinemaScore's announcement graphic showing the I Play Rocky poster beside an A+ grade badge
Photo: CinemaScore

What makes this A+ stand out is where recent ones have gone. Over the past few years the perfect grade has belonged mostly to faith-based releases and concert films, and a mainstream drama had not earned one since Top Gun: Maverick in 2022. An A+ is the industry’s clearest word-of-mouth signal: audiences do not just like the film, they leave the theater ready to tell everyone they know to see it, and films that earn one tend to play for months.

The grade matches everything else about the film’s run so far. Verified audiences have it at 98 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, ahead of its Certified Fresh 88 percent from critics. It opened on November 6 in just seven theaters and averaged $48,209 per screen, one of the strongest limited debuts of the year, and Amazon MGM Studios expanded it to 2,000 theaters this weekend, where it is projected to earn around $12 million.

The timing could not be better. The expansion weekend is the 50th anniversary of the original Rocky, which premiered on November 21, 1976, and as Trevor Decker News reported on Friday, the nationwide rollout arrived with a fresh batch of clips, including a legacy featurette narrated by Tom Brady. Fifty years after a broke, unknown Sylvester Stallone bet on himself, the film about that bet is winning over audiences the same way the original did.